BOV TALKS ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE BANKING WORLD
by Bank of Valletta
9th April 2024
by CSB Group
10th April 2023
When leading a financial services entity, in particular within the company service provision, one needs to be aware of the consequences of business decisions that could undermine the entity’s business policies, systems and the overall compliance culture. In this 5-part series of articles, I will analyse 5 business decisions, through the legislative references such decisions could fall foul of, the impact on the organisation these decisions could have, and attempt to suggest a course of action.
The problematic decision to be analysed in this article is that which causes the Compliance/AML divisions to be seen as business enablers, having their bonus scheme linked to new business KPIs.
The Company Services Providers Rule Book, issued by the Malta Financial Services Authority on the 15th March 2021, has expressed itself very clearly on this particular issue, specifically about the conflict of having AML/Compliance staff or effectively the 2nd line of defence in fighting ML/FT within a firm, in being client-facing and having their remuneration compromise their objectivity. ‘The relevant persons involved in the compliance function shall not be involved in the performance of services or activities which they monitor and shall be sufficiently independent from the client onboarding process; and the method of determining the remuneration of the relevant persons involved in the compliance function shall not compromise their objectivity and shall not be likely to do so’.[1]
Undoubtedly, it is important that the AML/Compliance division attains a reasonable level of commercial pragmatism[2] and that the procedures and processes of this division do not hinder the commercial aspect but compliments it by ensuring that new business onboarded is in line with entity’s Board risk appetite and done in accordance to prevailing AML rules and regulations. However, any current set-up with the AML/Compliance division seen as business enablers with their bonus scheme tied to new business, impinges directly on the independence and objectivity of the division and seriously undermines the compliance culture any Board needs to focus on building.
In addition, maintaining the current status breaches the CSP Rule Book and the MFSA may, ‘by virtue of the authority granted to it, impose administrative penalties, without recourse to a court of law, up to a maximum of €50,000’. [3]
From an MLRO standpoint, having the 2nd line of defence and members of this team with prejudiced independence and objectivity could result in personal sanctions, both administrative and criminal, especially if due to the division’s dereliction of duty towards AML and in favour of on-boarding business, results in the on-boarding of non-reputable, fraudulent, criminal business or sanctioned PEPs. This will cascade on the firm, with reputational, legal and operational damage.
It is recommended that the bonus scheme for the staff members of the AML/Compliance division is immediately amended. Any references to sales or onboarding of new business are removed.
Clear job descriptions and roles are drawn up removing any conflicting references that imparts from the independence and objectivity needed in such compliance roles and any KPIs linked to new business is replaced by compliance metrics. One would suggest to involve HR in revising any contractual references with conflicting duties and AML staff bonuses switched to a pre-determined amount or percentage of salary, linked to updated KPIs such as:
By putting the above in place, the Board will be also progressing towards a more balanced/compliance culture.
This article has been authored by Jean-Claude Cardona, CSB Group Operations & Finance Director. Contact us on https://www.csbgroup.com/contact-us/ for more information.
[1] Company Service Provider Rule Book, MFSA, March 2021, R3 8.4.
[2] ICA Manual, Module 5.
[3] Company Service Provider Rule Book, MFSA, March 2021, R5 2.2.
by Ganado Advocates
5th April 2024
by CSB Group
5th April 2024
by Bank of Valletta
21st March 2024
by Bank of Valletta
18th March 2024
by Ganado Advocates
4th March 2024
by Ganado Advocates
23rd February 2024
by HSBC Bank Malta p.l.c.
19th February 2024
by Bank of Valletta
29th January 2024
by Bank of Valletta
17th January 2024
by CSB Group
12th January 2024
by Ganado Advocates
3rd January 2024
by Ganado Advocates
3rd January 2024
by Ganado Advocates
3rd January 2024
by Bank of Valletta
28th November 2023
by Bank of Valletta
23rd November 2023
by Bank of Valletta
3rd November 2023
by Ganado Advocates
1st November 2023
by Ganado Advocates
1st November 2023
by Ganado Advocates
1st November 2023
by Griffiths + Associates Ltd
31st October 2023
by Ganado Advocates
16th October 2023
by Bank of Valletta
29th September 2023
by Bank of Valletta
31st August 2023
by Bank of Valletta
28th August 2023
by Ganado Advocates
16th August 2023
by Ganado Advocates
16th August 2023
by Ganado Advocates
11th August 2023
by APS Bank plc
31st July 2023
by Ganado Advocates
28th June 2023
by Ganado Advocates
28th June 2023
by Ganado Advocates
28th June 2023
by Ganado Advocates
26th May 2023
by Bank of Valletta
7th May 2023
by Infocredit Group Limited
3rd May 2023
by Bank of Valletta
14th April 2023
by Ganado Advocates
10th April 2023
by CSB Group
14th March 2023
by Ganado Advocates
24th February 2023
by CSB Group
21st February 2023
by Griffiths + Associates Ltd
20th February 2023
by FinanceMalta
14th February 2023
by Bank of Valletta
31st January 2023
by CSB Group
19th January 2023
by Ganado Advocates
13th January 2023
by Ganado Advocates
13th January 2023
by Bank of Valletta
27th December 2022
by Bank of Valletta
21st November 2022
by BNF Bank plc
18th November 2022
by Bank of Valletta
3rd November 2022
by FinanceMalta
28th October 2022
by BNF Bank plc
6th October 2022
by Bank of Valletta
16th September 2022
by Bank of Valletta
2nd September 2022
by CSB Group
31st August 2022
by Bank of Valletta
11th August 2022
by BNF Bank plc
10th August 2022
by Griffiths + Associates Ltd
29th July 2022
by Griffiths + Associates Ltd
25th July 2022
by BNF Bank plc
14th July 2022
by Bank of Valletta
3rd June 2022
by Infocredit Group Limited
19th May 2022
by The Malta Institute of Accountants
13th May 2022
by Griffiths + Associates Ltd
9th May 2022
by Griffiths + Associates Ltd
3rd May 2022
by Infocredit Group Limited
28th April 2022
by Infocredit Group Limited
8th April 2022
by Infocredit Group Limited
8th April 2022
by Ganado Advocates
24th February 2022
by Bank of Valletta
16th February 2022
by BNF Bank plc
12th January 2022
by BNF Bank plc
3rd December 2021
by Western Union Business Solutions
1st November 2021
by FinanceMalta
8th July 2021
by FinanceMalta
8th July 2021
by FinanceMalta
8th July 2021
by Bank of Valletta
28th June 2021
by FinanceMalta
18th June 2021
by Bank of Valletta
1st June 2021
by Bank of Valletta
26th May 2021
by Bank of Valletta
25th May 2021
by Bank of Valletta
18th May 2021
by Bank of Valletta
17th May 2021
by Bank of Valletta
7th May 2021
by FinanceMalta
29th April 2021
by Bank of Valletta
13th April 2021
by Bank of Valletta
18th February 2021
by Western Union Business Solutions
5th February 2021
by FinanceMalta
14th January 2021
by Bank of Valletta
4th January 2021
by Bank of Valletta
21st December 2020
by Bank of Valletta
18th December 2020
by Bank of Valletta
18th December 2020
by Bank of Valletta
30th November 2020
by Bank of Valletta
29th September 2020
by Infocredit Group Limited
23rd September 2020
by Bank of Valletta
14th September 2020
by Bank of Valletta
14th September 2020
by Bank of Valletta
2nd September 2020
by Bank of Valletta
19th August 2020
by APS Bank plc
3rd August 2020
by Bank of Valletta
31st July 2020
by Bank of Valletta
31st July 2020
by Ganado Advocates
17th July 2020
by FinanceMalta
10th June 2020