scroll to explore

An overview of trade-based money laundering

Credit & Financial Institutions

An overview of trade-based money laundering

by Mazars in Malta

23rd August 2021

Intro Video

Money launderers go through considerable effort (and creativity) to disguise the proceeds of their activity under the cover of legitimate business activity. In addition, experience has shown us that money launderers are keen to exploit vulnerabilities inherent in enforcement systems, undertaking cross-border transactions using complex structures.

Malta is not immune to this. Our financial services sector has grown considerably over the past years, with Malta becoming an attractive country of choice for international investors. Our favourable taxation system, based on tax refunds upon dividend distribution to non-resident shareholders, has for the past years attracted significant interest and generated considerable investment. Over time, various holding and trading entities, some with limited substance, were incorporated in Malta. Consequently, Malta is now more at risk of being used as a channel to launder proceeds of crime where money launderers can blend funds from their illicit activities in legal transactions.

It would be very wrong to think that Malta’s attractiveness to money launderers lies only in its tax system. Paradoxically, money launderers may be very happy to be taxed. Their prime motivation is to distance the funds from their illicit activity (layering process) with the ultimate aim of integrating ill-gotten funds (albeit net of the laundering costs) into the financial system, in order for them to use and enjoy the proceeds.

From a Malta jurisdiction perspective, it is likely that if local accountants, auditors, tax advisors and corporate services providers had to encounter cross-border money laundering activity, this would typically be in the layering phase of the cleaning process.

What is trade-based money laundering?

The Financial Action Task Force (FATF) defines trade-based money laundering (TBML) as “the process of disguising proceeds of crime and moving value through the use of trade transactions in an attempt to legitimise their illicit origins”. As in many money laundering schemes, the focus is not on the movement of goods, but rather on the movement of funds. The movement of funds in a TBML scheme requires collusion between parties who abuse of trade finance services to facilitate the trading of goods. These schemes would usually involve professional money launderers, like for example lawyers and accountants, who offer their services to the beneficiaries of illicit proceeds of crime by providing their expertise to disguise the source of funds to avoid detection, in exchange for a fee or commission.

Goodwilled accountants, corporate service providers and lawyers may also unwittingly find themselves at the centre of a cross-border trade-based money laundering scheme. Understanding the purpose of business, married with professional scepticism and an eye for detail, are some of the main weapons practitioners have in their armoury. However, even these qualities may be impaired due to “familiarity” and “commercial interests” – money launderers and their agents have an artful and convincing way of blurring “objectivity”.

Typical red flags for accountants to look out for

The following is a non-comprehensive list of some of the more common traits that may indicate the existence of a trade-based money laundering scheme. It goes without saying that one swallow does not necessarily make a summer, yet the existence of some of these traits may require closer analysis. In doing so, subject persons must be careful not to fall foul of their tipping-off obligations.

The volume of goods being shipped appears to be much larger than the regular business activity;
Goods are transported from or to a high-risk jurisdiction;
The payment of goods is made by third parties who do not appear to have any connection with the transaction;
Goods being shipped are considered to be high-risk goods for money laundering, or goods connected to high-risk industries, like for example precious metals or equipment for the oil and gas industry;
Discrepancies between the description of goods on the bill of lading and those included in the invoice could mean a false description of goods, over or under-invoicing, or over or under shipping;
Goods are transported through jurisdictions or entities for no apparent reason;
The goods purchased are to be sold immediately, typically to one or a few customers, with a back-to-back type of arrangement;
Credit terms are provided loosely without the expected levels of commercial guarantees and security in place;
Credit terms do not elicit the commensurate commercial reaction expected in an arm’s length transaction;
The buyer and/or seller does not demonstrate the necessary experience and/or standing to carry out such a transaction. Desktop internet research renders limited information thereon.
Communications are typically not carried out directly with the buyer and/or seller but through an agent.

CLICK HERE TO READ OUR CASE STUDY

The article was written jointly by Alan Craig and Rebekah Barthet. Alan Craig is the advisory partner at Mazars in Malta, specialising in internal audit, governance, money laundering and regulatory compliance. Rebekah Barthet is a forensic investigation and compliance senior manager at Mazars in Malta, specialising in investigation assignments and regulatory compliance.

This article first appeared in The Accountant magazine, issue 2 of 2021 of the Malta Institute of Accountants.

Credit & Financial Institutions

An overview of trade-based money laundering

Intro Video

What is trade-based money laundering?

Typical red flags for accountants to look out for

CLICK HERE TO READ OUR CASE STUDY

'Credit & Financial Institutions' Related News Articles

A creditor’s obligation to assess the creditworthiness of a consumer

BOV TALKS ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE BANKING WORLD

The MFSA consults on a draft Conduct of Business Rulebook for Banks

MFSA Shifts to Outcomes-Based Supervision in 2024

AIFMD II – A step closer to entry into force

The European Union Global Minimum Level of Taxation for Multinational Enterprise Groups and Large-Scale Domestic Groups Regulations 2024

BOV EXPERTS DISCUSS ECONOMY AND INVESTMENT BASICS WITH RETAIL CLIENTS

Bank of Valletta has supported this year’s opera by Gioachino Rossini – ‘Armida’

EU AML-CTF Package taking shape: Compromise text for AMLR and 6AMLD published

Changing the terms of a credit agreement and forbearance policies and measures: new obligations on lenders in consumer and residential property credit agreements

BOV launches revamped cutting-edge website

The HSBC Malta Foundation supports Three-Year UM Research Project through RIDT

Bank Of Valletta extends Partnership Agreement with Heritage Malta

BOV RETROSPECTIVE EXHIBITION FEATURING WORKS BY NOEL GALEA BASON OFFICIALLY INAUGURATED

Goal-line Defenders: Scoring Victory Against Financial Crime with the Three Lines of AML/CFT Defence

Agreement reached on the establishment of the Anti-Money Laundering Authority (“AMLA”)

FIAU Thematic Review on Company Service Providers when providing Company Formation Services

Directive 93/13/EEC and mandatory statutory or regulatory provisions in consumer contracts

2023 SEES 151 BOV EMPLOYEES GRADUATING

BOV SELLS PORTFOLIO OF NON-PERFORMING LOANS

MALTA Nomad Residence Permit, New Tax Rules.

BOV Boosting Employee Retention through Occupational Pension Schemes

Keeping Tabs on Market Perception and Knowledge about Investments

BOV Announces Profit Before Tax of €163.5 million as at September 2023

Proposed amendments to the Exclusive Economic Zone Act and ancillary laws

MFSA Circular regarding various amendments to the Investment Services Rulebooks

MiCA Update: Consultation Process on the Proposed Updates to Chapter 3 of the VFA Rulebook

Continuing to disclose the topic EU funding for Startups ¦ Startup Definition

BOV keeps up momentum in educating customers about scams

Auditing iGaming Entities

Malta: a state-of-the-art regulatory framework for cryptocurrencies

ESMA issues Second Consultation Package under MiCA

Standard and Poor’s (S&P) upgrades Bank of Valletta’s rating to stable

BOV Asset Management Seminar Discusses Best Practices in Investments

BANK OF VALLETTA ACQUIRES NEW FUNDING TO RELAUNCH THE BOV SME INVEST PACKAGE

BOV Introduces New Digital Portal to Update Customer Records

EU Court’s Landmark Ruling: Restricting Financial Ties to Combat Money Laundering and Terrorism Financing

ESMA and EBA issue Inaugural Consultation Packages under MICA

ESMA issues public statement in relation to sustainability disclosures in prospectuses

FIAU publishes its AML / CFT Supervisory Plan for 2023 – 2024

Reforming Digital Payments – Introducing the new Payment Services proposals

APS Bank delivers best-ever half-yearly results, to pay interim dividend

New Digital Experience For BNF Bank Customers

Proposals for an improved European Banking Union framework – Part II

Proposals for an improved European Banking Union framework – Part I

Opposing trade mark registrations in the realm of financial institutions

Over 24,000 customers respond to BOV’s call for feedback

BOV puts Mobility in the Spotlight on World Bicycle Day

BOV Goes Green for Mental Health

BOV Volunteers at GSSE 2023

The new notified PIFs framework: MFSA publishes consultation document on regulatory changes

MiCA obtains green light from European Council

ESMA postpones annual IFRS amendment of ESEF to 2024

BOV Launches Investor Education Sessions

MiCA – Landmark crypto regulation approved by EU Parliament

BOV ISSUES WARNING ON SCAM CALLS

BOV Asset Management Limited launches the Global Multi-Asset Thematic 60 Fund managed by Fidelity International

MALTA COUNTRY ANALYSIS REPORT

INFOCREDIT GROUP AMONG THE SPONSORS OF MALTA FINANCIAL CRIME COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE 2023

Business Decisions that undermine the Compliance Culture – Part 5

BOV Offers MAPFRE MSV Life Capital Guaranteed Product

Business Decisions that undermine the Compliance Culture – Part 4

Becoming a Data Driven Organisation

Business Decisions that undermine the Compliance Culture – Part 3

BANK OF VALLETTA PROMOTES HEALTHY LIFESTYLES AND ROTA INITIATIVE

Business Decisions that undermine the Compliance Culture – Part 2

ELTIF 2.0 published in the Official Journal of the European Union

The INSIGHT Interview: David Power, CEO of BNF Bank

Sustainable Finance and the Impact on the Financial Services Sector in Malta

Bank of Valletta commemorates International Women’s Day

EU’s Green Taxation: Tackling Climate Change through Tax

The classification of cryptoassets under the new Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation

Business Decisions that undermine the Compliance Culture – The MLRO Reporting Lines